More history.
All the while, I had made an incredible connection with a girl. We met in church at the age of 15. She became my best friend – and later became a great lover. The first love I had ever known. The greatest love I’ve ever known. We spent all of our free time with each other. We’d spend hours talking on the phone when we weren’t with each other. We were intensely attracted to each other. We made out every chance we had. We dry humped till orgasm whenever alone. We had phone sex all the time. We were both ready to get married at the age of 18, and we would have if we had the financial means to make it happen. Instead, we broke up.
After being with other people and “sowing our wild oats” - as they say – we ended up together again. Now in our early 20’s and having another 4-year relationship with ups and downs, with great moments and also our share of tears. It culminated in our living together. We started to build a life together, this time as adults. This time instead of singing in the choir together we were going to parties. One time, she got invited to a swinger party. It was more of a meeting place for would be swingers as there was no actual sex happening on the premises. We attended a few swingers’ parties. These parties weren’t anything too crazy, as they were held in your average bar or lounge. They were by invite only, and no single guys were allowed. The people that attended turned out to be normal. No one was too eccentric or too far removed from normal; they were just regular people adding a lil spice to their life. We made some friends. Kept attending the parties. We started to prefer them to regular clubs, for the simple fact that the people were a lot friendlier and down-to-earth at these parties. Not as pretentious or egotistical as the people you’d find at the average club or latest NYC “hot spot”.
This is where I started to see options. Options in the way we can handle our relationship. I watched her kiss other women and I was ok with it. I watched other women kiss her nipples, and rub her pussy, and grab her ass, and I enjoyed it. Now, being the normal red-blooded human male that I am, I started to wonder about the “threesome.” I grew tired of sitting back and watching her have all the fun at these parties. I never pressured her about it, and rarely even hinted at the idea of a threesome. I just assumed that if we went to enough of these parties that some day it would just happen. It’ll just naturally progress to that level. Much to my dismay, it never did. The highlight of my fun at these parties was a late night game of spin the bottle where we actually kissed a couple of other girls and I got to participate. Then we stopped going to these parties altogether. Somehow the scene just died out for us.
We went on with our relationship as normal. What she didn’t know, and what I never expressed to her, was that I never forgot about the possibilities of living a swingers lifestyle. I didn’t know how to mention it, the fear of being seen as a dirty, rotten, perverted, narcissistic, egotistical, womanizing, asshole kept me silent.
Today I’m 28, and we just broke up again. The animal that I was trying to keep in the dark had grown and was now starting to rattle the cage – a bit too loudly. And the noise was disrupting our relationship. My desire for other women started to seep through my fingers as I held my hand over the bubbling shit I kept bottled up inside.
Instead of being honest with the only love I’ve ever known, I was now lying to her about my feelings, my desires, my porn habits, how many times I’d masturbate, and what I thought about when I did. Her romantic ideals about relationships clashed with my realistic approach to partnerships. I wanted to be an open book with her. Open myself to the point where you wouldn’t be able to tell where I ended and she began. I was honest about what I was feeling. What I feel. I don’t think monogamy is possible for me.